Israel says Nasrallah’s killing disrupted flow of Iran funds to Hezbollah
A banner of Hassan Nasrallah in Iran
Israel’s killing of Hezbollah commanders, including Hassan Nasrallah, along with recent airstrikes on its infrastructure, has significantly disrupted the group’s funding from Iran, according to a senior Israeli intelligence official.
While in Kuwait as part of his Middle East tour, Iran’s Foreign Minister said that none of its neighboring Arab states would allow Israel to use their territory or airspace for any planned attack on Iran.
"All of our neighbors have assured us that they will not allow their territory or airspace to be used against the Islamic Republic of Iran," Abbas Araghchi stated in a press conference.
As part of his regional mission, Tehran's top diplomat has been intensifying efforts to rally support from Arab nations in response to the looming threat of an Israeli attack, visiting about a dozen states.
Iran’s diplomatic outreach to its neighbors has intensified following its own missile strike on Israel on October 1, during which over 180 missiles were launched. This marked the second missile strike initiated by Tehran against Israel this year. Israel has said it will retaliate against the missile barrage and is preparing its military for such an eventuality.
Iran's attack followed Israel’s assassinations of top leaders of militant groups backed by Iran, including those of Hezbollah and Hamas, and the Islamic Revolutionary Guards (IRGC).
As Tehran continues its efforts to engage with its neighbors, a report by the US-funded news outlet Alhurra this weekcited a senior Israeli source stating that Arab nations along the Persian Gulf have urged Israel to deliver a decisive blow to Iran.
The report further suggested that the Arab nations also view this moment as an opportunity to weaken Tehran through support of Israel’s military actions.
Arab nations are aware that Iran could retaliate against their oil facilities if they are seen as supporting attacks on its oil or nuclear sites by Washington or Tel Aviv – particularly, in light of the 2019 Saudi Aramco attacks, which inflicted significant damage on the kingdom's oil-dependent economy and were widely attributed to Iran. Their willingness to engage with Iran in recent weeks could be an attempt to lessen the likelihood of any Iranian hostile act during tit-for-tat attacks with Israel.
Iran's Foreign Minister, however, claimed there is a shared understanding to prevent tension and escalation.
"The Islamic Republic of Iran does not seek war in the region, although we are prepared for war. We have made every effort to reduce tensions, but we are both ready and capable of confronting any scenario,” Araghchi stated.
The foreign minister of the Islamic Republic, which has faced accusations of international crimes since coming to power in 1979, also expressed hope that international laws would prevent Israel from attacking its nuclear facilities.
He further claimed that "all the countries" in the region have informed Tehran of their opposition to any attack on Iran, particularly targeting its nuclear infrastructure.
"I emphasize again, however Israel attacks Iran, Iran will respond in kind," he said.
Recent statistics from Iran’s Central Bank indicate that the private sector has been largely eliminated from large-scale foreign trade and replaced with government entities, which are engaged in billions of dollars of imports.
The data shows that these entities were the primary recipients of foreign currencies from the Central Bank that is the repository of US dollars, euros and other stable currencies importers need to conduct business. As large-scale currency trading is controlled by the government, it has set up various rates. For essential imports it provides dollars at half the free market rate, subsidizing food and medicines.
Meanwhile, customs data reveals that the majority of the country's exports come from government-controlled petrochemical, steel, oil and gas products, indicating the gradual exclusion of the private sector from Iran's foreign trade.
The latest Central Bank statistics show that since the beginning of the current fiscal year (March 20), a total of $37.2 billion has been allocated for the import of goods.
On October 15, Mohammad Rezvani-Far, the head of Iran's Customs Administration, announced that during this period, non-oil exports reached $29.5 billion, while imports amounted to $37 billion.
The key point here is that the Central Bank recently reported that in the first half of the current fiscal year (March 20 to September 20), it allocated $32.4 billion to the ministries of Industry, Agriculture, and Health for imports. Customs data also shows that the total value of imports in the first six months of this fiscal year was $32.5 billion. In other words, the private sector has been effectively sidelined from the country’s import activities.
Foreign currency allocation by the Central Bank for imported goods
The Central Bank plans to allocate a total of $55 billion to the ministries of Industry, Agriculture, and Health for imports during this fiscal year. Last year, Iran imported $66.2 billion worth of goods, $1.9 billion of which was gold bullion. If Iran's imports remain at last year's level, 85% of the total imports will be handled by the three government ministries, leaving only 15% to be managed by other government and semi-governmental entities, including the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) and the real private sector.
Approximately, $8.13 billion of the foreign currency allocated by the Central Bank for the import of food and medicine was provided at the rate of 285,000 rials, or less than half of the free market rate. The rest was supplied at higher, but still preferential rates. The remaining imports were made at the free market exchange rate, which stood at around 600,000 rials per dollar.
Central Bank and customs data show that the real private sector lacks access to the government's subsidized currency at the rate of 285,000 rials and has very limited access to the higher preferential rate. As a result, the private sector must rely solely on the free market exchange rate to import goods, severely limiting its ability to compete.
$7 Billion Trade Deficit in the First Half of the Year
Iranian customs data indicates a $7 billion deficit in the country’s non-oil foreign trade during the first half of the current fiscal year.
Last fiscal year, Iran’s non-oil trade deficit also reached an unprecedented figure of $17 billion. Customs data shows that in the first half of the current year, non-oil exports amounted to $25.8 billion, while imports reached $32.5 billion.
Although Iran earns revenue from oil exports, capital flight from the country is also significant. Since 2018, coinciding with US sanctions, Iran's capital account has been negative.
For instance, last year, Iran exported $36 billion worth of oil and oil-related products, and the overall trade balance of the country was a positive $18 billion. However, the latest Central Bank report indicates that during the first nine months of last year, over $20 billion in capital fled the country.
Additionally, Central Bank data shows that Iran's service trade balance is consistently negative by around $7 to $8 billion each year.
It is unclear exactly what the state of Iran’s foreign currency reserves is, given the trade imbalance and widespread capital flight. However, in an effort to slow the decline of the rial, the Central Bank has been forced to inject large amounts of foreign currency into the market.
Whatever Israel targets in Iran won't be a one-time strike but the beginning of a larger war between the two nations, a senior Israeli insider and former military official told Iran International.
“This attack is just the beginning of a long war between Israel and Iran,” said Brigadier General (res.) Amir Avivi. “There will be a big attack, but one of many."
Avivi, a close friend and Caesarea neighbor of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, is regularly consulted by key government ministers.
The targets for Israel’s retaliation to Tehran’s ballistic missile attack on Oct 1 have yet to be disclosed, but Avivi said what Israel chooses to strike is not of importance because that’s just the beginning and not a means to an end.
He warned that Israel’s endgame is to ensure that Iran does not become a nuclear power.
“Israel has also prepared quite a few surprises for Iran,” he said over a zoom interview with Iran International.
When asked what he meant by “surprises”, he would not elaborate.
“I can’t go into details, but we’ve prepared many, many interesting surprises,” he added.
Avivi, who retired from the Israeli military seven years ago, was responsible for the audit of military readiness and held several senior roles. He’s also the founder and chairman of the Israeli Defense and Security Forum (IDSF). His organization is made up of more than 30,000 former Israeli military soldiers and officers and is influential in Israeli politics.
How long he anticipates the potential war between Iran and Israel to last will likely depend on the outcome of the US presidential elections, according to Avivi.
“If the US decides to join with Israel and build a coalition and deal with the Iran military, what Israel did in a week or two can be done in Iran in a few days if the US leads an attack. If the US continues with their policies of appeasement. Then Israel will have to deal with this alone and this will take time.”
He feels that a Harris presidency would continue its policy of appeasement to Iran, forcing Israel to be alone in its fight, believing that a Trump administration would assist Israel in a military coalition. He foresees an Abrahamic alliance with Sunni countries in opposition of a Shia axis.
A red line: Drone attack on Israeli Prime Minister residence
Avivi said his wife was awoken from the sound of a drone attack on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu private residence in their northern coastal town of Caesarea Saturday morning. His wife, an ambulance driver, immediately drove to the scene and found superficial damage to the home.
Netanyahu and his wife, who frequent their seaside home on weekends, were not home at the time.
In a statement posted to X, the Israeli Prime Minister blamed Iran for the alleged attempt on his life.
“The attempt by Iran’s proxy Hezbollah to assassinate me and my wife today was a grave mistake.”
Avivi described the drone attack as legitimacy to go after Iran’s leadership.
When asked if that would mean Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamanei, he replied yes.
Aviv said Israel sees an opportunity here, and dealing with Iran, which is located more than 1,000 miles away, is a process that will take time.
Iran has distanced itself from the attempted attack on Netanyahu’s residence and pointed the finger at Hezbollah.
However, Mohsen Sazegara, a journalist and political analyst, told Iran International that Saturday’s attack was carried out by the IRGC, which has assumed control of Hezbollah's operations following the assassination of its leader, Hassan Nasrallah.
The leak of US assessments on Israel's preparations for an attack on Iran has embarrassed Washington and left officials scrambling for the source of the leak and spawned theories on how such sensitive information could have emerged.
"That is not supposed to happen, and it's unacceptable when it does," White House National Security spokesperson John Kirby said, adding that the source of the leak or whether it was the result of a hack had not yet been determined.
“The president remains deeply concerned about any leakage of classified information into the public domain,” Kirby said.
The highly classified information relates to intelligence gleaned from US satellites relating to what it describes as preparations for an Israeli air attack in Iran in retaliation for an Oct. 1 missile barrage on the Jewish state.
The documents first appeared online Friday on the Telegram messaging app and quickly spread among Telegram channels popular with Iranians known as the Middle East Spectator. The platform's account on X lists its location as the Islamic Republic of Iran.
The National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency and the National Security Agency were the alleged authors of the intelligence, which was meant only for the "Five Eyes", an alliance of intelligence sharing countries comprising the US, Canada, the UK, New Zealand and Australia.
Holden Tripplet, a former FBI counterintelligence official told Iran International on Sunday the leak could have been aimed at scaling back the scope of Israel's plans.
“The leak, if done without official sanction by the US government, may have been intended to dissuade an Israeli strike or at least limit the overall retaliatory response," said Tripplet, who spent 15 years in the FBI.
The leak earned criticism of the Biden-Harris administration from a usual quarter, Republicans in congress.
Mississippi Senator Roger Wicker posted to X on Tuesday cited the case of Ariane Tabatabai, a senior Pentagon official with alleged ties to Iran.
An Iran International Investigation found Tabatabai was part of an official Iranian influence network in Washington DC advocating for Tehran and its policy goals. There has been no evidence connecting Tabatabai to the release of classified documents.
"Last year, I called for suspending Ariane Tabatabai’s security clearance for her role in an Iranian info op. Amazingly, she’s still in her job," Wicker wrote.
"The latest apparent leak to an Iranian Telegram channel reflects the Biden-Harris administration's tolerance of insider threats."
"A lot of people have been worried that there are Iranian sympathizers in the Biden-Harris White House. It‘s very disturbing and the administration needs to come clean on this," former US national security advisor, John Bolton, said on Monday.
US Iran envoy Robert Malley was suspended last year after what media reports citing government sources described as mishandling classified information. He was placed on unpaid leave and had his security clearance suspended.
In February 2021, Malley selected Ariane Tabatabai, then a Middle East fellow at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, for his State Department team to assist in negotiations with Iran. She served in that position for almost 15 months.
US-funded outlet Alhurra cited an Israeli source saying Arab nations along the Persian Gulf have urged Israel to deliver a decisive blow to Iran even as Tehran continues efforts to engage with those states to de-escalate tensions with Israel.
"Gulf countries have sent messages to Israel stressing the need for its response to Iran to be strict and clear," Alhurra cited the source as saying.
"Israel is receiving contacts and requests from Gulf countries to inform it in advance of the expected response so that it can take precautions in the event of a counterattack," the channel added.
Israel says it will retaliate for an Oct. 1 attack in which Iran launched over 180 ballistic missiles at the Jewish state. Iran has publicly said it is not seeking full-scale war but officials have emphasized the country is prepared for a conflict should one arise.
Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi sought to shore up support among regional nations to mitigate Israel’s actions during a recent tour of the Middle East which included visits to Saudi Arabia and Iraq .
Over the weekend, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accused Iran of orchestrating an assassination attempt after three drones targeted one of his residences. Neither Netanyahu nor his wife were at home during the incident.
The attempted strike comes just days after the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) killed Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in a precision operation in southern Gaza.
“The attempt by Iran’s proxy Hezbollah to assassinate me and my wife today was a grave mistake,” Netanyahu said in a statement on Saturday night, adding Israel would “eliminate the terrorists and those who dispatch them”.
Alhurra’s interviews cited former Israeli military spokesperson Jonathan Conricus saying the assassination attempt on Netanyahu could represent a miscalculation by Iran by providing Israel with a justification for a broader response.
The news outlet further reports that Israel, while coordinating with regional militaries under US Central Command (CENTCOM), sees its response to Iranian missile attacks as a strategic opportunity to assert its military power in the Middle East and counter the threats from Tehran, both direct and indirect.
Israeli sources, including Conricus, emphasized to Alhurra that Israel's goal is not just to shift the balance of power between Israel and Iran, but to reshape the broader dynamics of the Middle East.
The report suggests that Arab nations on the Persian Gulf also view this moment as an opportunity to weaken Tehran through support of Israel’s military actions.
While in Germany last Friday, US President Joe Biden told reporters that he has a good understanding of how and when Israel plans to respond to Iran’s missile attack but declined to provide further details.
Although the timing and specifics of Israel's retaliation remain unclear, sources informed CNN last week that it is expected to take place before the US presidential election on November 5.
Previous reports from multiple news outlets indicate that Israel has assured the US it will refrain from targeting nuclear or energy infrastructure, though other reports suggest that all options are still on the table.
The Israeli military intensified its campaign against Hezbollah’s leadership with the July 30 assassination of Fuad Shukr, a key aide to Nasrallah, followed by multiple airstrikes over the next two months that culminated in the killing of the group’s leaderon September 27.
The airstrikes targeting the group’s leaders and infrastructure have created new challenges in Hezbollah's financial operations, which could have far-reaching consequences for its military capabilities, an Israeli intelligence official told reporters in a briefing on Sunday.
Iran provides most of Hezbollah’s training, weapons, and funding, sending the group hundreds of millions of dollars each year, according to the US State Department.
"Every month around $50 million comes from Iran to Syria and in Syria, they're transferred to Hezbollah. Some of the money is actually physical dollars, some of it is transferred to Syria through an oil agreement that Iran gives oil to Syria, which is then changed into money in Syria," the Israeli official explained.
The official said the money is also transferred by diplomatic figures coming from Iran to Lebanon through the Beirut International Airport, carrying suitcases of dollars to fund Hezbollah.
“Until about a month ago, Hezbollah's economic situation was pretty steady, because they received the funding from Iran on a very, very clear way every month. It came at the right time over the past few months. After that, a few things changed. They aren't able to receive funding as easily," the senior official said.
'Extreme rise in Hezbollah's expenses'
Disruption in money transfer is not the only financial problem Hezbollah is facing. Israel says the recent campaign against the Lebanese group has extremely increased their payments, as Hezbollah now faces additional financial burdens, including paying for more operatives, weapons, and the damages caused by the airstrikes, according to the Israeli official.
The official warned that Iran could easily resume funding after the war unless Israel systematically targets Hezbollah’s financial network.
The intelligence official made the remarks in a briefing that was held ahead of IDF airstrikes against multiple branches of Qard al-Hasan, a financial institution linked to Hezbollah in Beirut, southern Lebanon, and the Bekaa Valley.
Al-Qard al-Hasan is officially a non-profit charity institution operating outside the Lebanese financial system, and one of the tools by which Hezbollah entrenches its support among the country’s Shia population.
The branches hit by Israeli airstrikes had been evacuated weeks ago, according to pro-Hezbollah media. Therefore, their destruction is not expected to hugely impact Hezbollah’s financial capabilities. However, the target seems to be the Shia community’s trust in Hezbollah.
“The main objective is to is to affect the trust between Hezbollah and a lot of the Shia community that uses this association as a banking system, because economically speaking, a lot of it is based on the fact that there are people using it,” the Israeli official said Sunday.
As Israeli airstrikes continue to target Hezbollah's financial and operational infrastructure, the long-term effects on Hezbollah’s economic stability and military capabilities remain uncertain. However, Israeli officials stress the importance of maintaining pressure to disrupt the group's funding pipeline.
“They are under pressure at this point, but obviously it's something that unless we harm it on a systematic level, it's something that they could recuperate with pretty easily if Iran just gives the funding on the day after war. And that's why it's something that we really have target at this point on it,” the Israeli intelligence official said.
While Hezbollah has lost almost all its commanders and senior leaders in the Israeli airstrikes and targeted assassinations over the past three months, it does not seem to be losing momentum, continuing its daily rocket, missile, and drone attacks against Israel, going as far as hitting the residence of Prime Minister Netanyahu.