EU backs Arab demands for Iran to end 'occupation' of islands
European Council President Charles Michel, Bahrain's Prime Minister and Crown Prince Sheikh Salman bin Hamad al-Khalifa, Deputy Prime Minister of United Arab Emirates Sheikh Maktoum bin Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum and Saudi Arabia Crown Prince and Prime Minister Mohammed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud stand during the joint European Union and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) summit, in Brussels, Belgium October 16, 2024
The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) and the European Union (EU) have jointly urged Iran to relinquish control of three Persian Gulf islands, which it has held since 1971 following Britain's withdrawal from the region.
The joint statement, issued on Wednesday during the first EU-GCC summit in Brussels, urges Iran to end its control of Greater Tunb, Lesser Tunb, and Abu Musa, islands claimed by the United Arab Emirates (UAE) after it gained independence following Britain's withdrawal.
"We call on Iran to end its occupation of the three islands of the United Arab Emirates, Greater Tunb, Lesser Tunb, and Abu Musa, which constitutes a violation of the sovereignty of the UAE and the principles of the Charter of the UN," the statement read.
Iran quickly dismissed the accusations. Abbas Araghchi, Iran’s foreign minister, took to social media, condemning the joint EU-GCC statement. “The three islands have always belonged to Iran and will forever remain as such. Era of European malign 'divide & rule' interference in our region is long over,” Araghchi posted on X.
Iran asserts that the islands have always been part of its territory, maintaining that it has never relinquished ownership. On the other hand, the UAE contends that the islands were under the control of the Qasimi sheikhs throughout the 19th century, with these rights subsequently passing to the UAE in 1971.
The islands were placed under British control in 1921, but on November 30, 1971, just one day after British forces withdrew and two days before the UAE officially became a federation, Iran's then-monarch, Mohammad Reza Shah, dispatched the Iranian navy to seize control of all three islands. Iranian forces remain stationed there to this day, with Abu Musa being the only island with a civilian population, numbering fewer than two thousand.
Abu Moussa, one of the three Iranian islands in the Persian Gulf
Arab nations have frequently voiced support for the UAE's claims, but the EU’s backing of this stance marks a significant shift in European policy. The statement aligns with growing international pressure on Iran with sanctions being imposed globally for its ongoing nuclear program, rights abuses at home and ongoing support for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
Esmail Baghaei, spokesperson for Iran’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, also rejected the EU-GCC claims. “This is a clear indication of the member states' lack of commitment to the principles and objectives of the United Nations Charter, especially the principle of respect for national sovereignty and the territorial integrity of states,” Baghaei said.
Tensions over the islands have been exacerbated by international interventions. In June, China supported the UAE’s claims during a meeting with Emirati officials, prompting a rebuke from Tehran. Similarly, Russia’s backing of the UAE in December drew an angry response from Iranian authorities.
The joint EU-GCC statement also emphasized the broader security concerns linked to Iran’s regional actions with its proxies currently engaged in a joint front against Israel as well as enacting a blockade on global shipping.
The statement called for Iran to halt its advancing nuclear program, which has raised alarms over potential weaponization, and demanded a cessation of missile and drone production, citing threats to regional and international peace. "We stress the importance of ensuring the peaceful nature of the Iranian nuclear program," the statement read.
European Council President Charles Michel walks with Estonia's Prime Minister Kristen Michal on the day of their bilateral meeting, during the joint European Union and the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) summit, in Brussels, Belgium October 16, 2024.
Additionally, the statement underscored the need for Iran to comply with international obligations under the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT). Both the GCC and the EU expressed disappointment over the progress of Iran's nuclear program in the last five years.
“We regret that Iran’s unabated nuclear advances over the last five years have made a return to the JCPOA increasingly difficult,” the statement added, further urging Tehran to pursue regional de-escalation and non-interference in neighboring countries’ internal affairs.
This year, the head of the UN's nuclear program, Rafael Grossi, warned Iran is "weeks not months" away from a nuclear weapon, as Tehran has barred a third of their nuclear inspectors.
The United States launched strikes on five Houthi key weapons storage facilities in Yemen on Wednesday, as part of ongoing efforts to weaken the Iran-backed group amid its maritime blockade of the Red Sea.
The blockade in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden region has seen dozens of seamen taken hostage, four deaths and two ships sunk amid nearly 100 attacks since November 2023.
Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin said in a statement: "US forces targeted several of the Houthis' underground facilities housing various weapons components of types that the Houthis have used to target civilian and military vessels throughout the region.”
The US is leading a more than 20-nation coalition to combat the blockade, with several operations being carried out alongside the UK.
“CENTCOM forces targeted the Houthi's hardened underground facilities housing missiles, weapons components, and other munitions used to target military and civilian vessels throughout the region,” a statement from CENTCOM said.
A Saudi-led coalition has been fighting the group in a war which has left millions displaced and tens of thousands killed.
Earlier this month, the US carried out 15 strikes against Houthi targets amid the maritime blockade which was instigated by Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, in allegiance with Iran-backed Hamas in Gaza, at war with Israel.
It has since disrupted global shipping, sending global commodity prices soaring as vessels detour on longer, more time-consuming routes. Along with the Houthis, Iran’s proxies in Syria, Lebanon, and Iraq have joined the fight against Israel since Hamas invaded Israel on October 7 last year, sparking a region-wide conflict.
US CENTCOM said US Air Force and US Navy assets, including US Air Force B-2 Spirit long-range stealth bombers, were part of Wednesday’s operation.
“The employment of the B-2 bomber demonstrates US global strike capabilities to reach these targets, when necessary, anytime, anywhere,” said a statement. “Our battle damage assessments are underway and do not indicate civilian casualties.”
The US strike, coming as Israeli retaliation against Iran looms, may serve as a message to Tehran, signaling Washington's readiness to take military action based on its assessment of regional security needs.
Israel has also conducted multiple strikes on Houthi facilities in Yemen since October 7 as it continues to defend itself against missile and drone attacks Iran’s proxies.
On the one-year anniversary of the Hamas attack which led to the death of at least 1,100 mostly civilians and saw 251 hostages taken to Gaza, the Houthis launched a surface-to-surface missile towards Tel Aviv, intercepted by Israel’s air defenses.
An opinion poll conducted by a government-owned agency in Iran to gauge university students' attitudes toward cultural and social issues has revealed insights into how they spend their leisure time and where they get their news.
The poll, conducted by ISPA, the polling agency of the Iranian Students News Agency (ISNA), in May 2024 and recently released, surveyed students at government-owned universities in Iran. It covers a range of topics, including students' use of messaging services and social networks, as well as their consumption of music, movies, and TV series.
Based on the ISPA poll, 79.5 percent of Iranian students use messaging services and social media daily. Among the other daily activities of students are listening to the music (66%), spending time with friends (57.6%), athletic activity (21%), listening to podcasts (19.4%), watching movies and TV series (18.1%), reading books and eBooks (18%), and playing computer games (13.3%).
According to the poll, Iranian students spend an average of 233 minutes (nearly four hours) on social media and messaging services every day.
Telegram is the most popular messaging and social media platform among Iranian students, with 89.5% using it daily. The usage of other platforms is as follows: Instagram (85.7%), WhatsApp (66.7%), YouTube (50.4%), Ita (38.4%), Rubika (29.6%), Twitter/X (23.5%), Baleh (20.8%), Soroush Plus (14.8%), Facebook (10.9%), TikTok (9.7%), Clubhouse (5%), and Threads (4.9%).
The top four social media platforms, along with many others, are foreign services banned by the Iranian government and blocked by internet censors. To access these platforms, users rely on VPNs and other tools to bypass censorship. In contrast, Iranian platforms are not widely trusted, as the government maintains full control over data traffic. Iranians primarily use these domestic platforms for practical purposes, such as accessing government services, paying bills, and banking. This lack of trust explains why foreign platforms remain far more popular than the government-controlled Iranian social media sites.
Another ISPA poll conducted in September revealed that social media and messaging platform usage among the general Iranian population differs from that of university students. Instagram is the most popular platform among the broader population, with 56% of users, followed by Telegram (39.3%) and WhatsApp (33.3%). Among Iranian platforms, Ita and Rubika are the most frequently used, each with over 28% of users, excluding university students.
ISPA's poll indicates that Iranian websites, news agencies, and local social media platforms are the primary news sources for most Iranians. However, other studies, including the Gamaan poll, show that international social media platforms are Iranians' top source of news.
According to ISPA’s poll of 2,250 Iranian students, over 25% get their news from domestic social media platforms, over 20% from international social media, 12% from state TV, 8% from foreign-based satellite TV, nearly 5% from friends and peers, and less than 1% from newspapers.
In contrast, a Gamaan poll of over 27,000 individuals found that Iran International TV (33%) and Manoto TV (30%)—both London-based—are the most popular media outlets in Iran. The poll revealed that 92% of respondents rely on social media for news about Iran and the world, 41% on satellite TV, 32% on news websites, and 14% on Iranian state television for daily updates.
Rights watchdog Freedom House ranked Iran as having the world’s third most repressive internet environment and lambasted the Islamic Republic for criminalizing online criticism to boost voter turnout and legitimize its presidential elections.
"(Authorities) criminalized any content that encouraged election boycotts or protests, or that criticized candidates ... (for) higher voter turnout to make the election seem legitimate, despite the arbitrary disqualification of most candidates," the group said in a report on Thursday.
The Iranian judiciary had warned that electoral laws prohibited candidates and their supporters from using foreign social media platforms, nearly all of which are blocked in the country, forcing the population to use Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) to bypass bans.
This was particularly evident in the lead-up to Iran’s snap presidential election, called after the sudden death of Ebrahim Raisi in a helicopter crash.
In June, the Iranian Press Supervisory Board issued a directive warning that violators of electoral rules would face severe punishment, including a sentence of 74 lashes.
The instructions specified that disseminating content aimed at “the boycott of the elections and the lowering of participation ... (or) organizing any form of unauthorized protest gathering, strike, or sit-in” would be considered a crime.
The election campaign involved a boisterous contest among the 80 registered candidates, six of whom were approved by Iran's unelected Guardian Council.
'Internet freedom repression'
The latest Freedom House report ranks Iran as the world's third most repressive country in terms of internet freedom, trailing only behind Myanmar and China, which jointly hold the first position.
Among Middle Eastern countries, Iran received the lowest overall score of 12 points on Freedom on the Net's 100-point scale behind Bahrain and Saudi Arabia.
Iran has a long history of stringent censorship, blocking tens of thousands of websites over the past two decades. Traditional media, literature, and cinema are also closely monitored, with content assessed for compliance with Islamic principles and political loyalty.
During his campaign, President Masoud Pezeshkian had pledged to lift internet filtering - a promise that resonated with millions of Iranians.
However, Pezeshkian recently ordered the Supreme Council of Cyberspace to crack down on anti-filtering software, leaving his supporters confused and disappointed as many Iranians still depend on VPNs to connect with the outside world and conduct business.
Reformist political activist Hassan Asadi-Zeidabadi expressed his frustration on social media, posting on X: “I can’t understand the meaning of this order about anti-filtering software and how it can help the removal of filtering.”
Last year, Freedom House cited a significant decline in Iran’s internet freedom in 2023, largely due to the government’s intensified efforts to quash protests linked to the Woman, Life, Freedom protests of 2022.
Sparked by the death of Mahsa Amini in police custody, the uprising was met with a violent crackdown and led to a marked drop in Iran’s internet freedom scores.
Iran trained most of its cyber might away from the United States toward Israel since the Gaza war began last year, according to a report by technology giant Microsoft.
"Iranian nation-state actors used ransomware in a cyber-enabled influence operation, marketing stolen Israeli dating website data," Microsoft said.
Following October 7, when Iran-backed Hamas led an attack on Israel, the report cites a marked increase in cyber operations aimed at Israel. From October 7, 2023 to July 2024, "nearly half of the Islamic Republic's cyber operations… targeted Israeli companies", it said.
Microsoft: "Example of Iran’s targeting shift following the start of the Israel-Hamas conflict."
Iran's cyber efforts are not confined to Israel. The report adds that Iranian and Russian actors are leveraging the ongoing conflicts to spread "divisive and misleading messages through propaganda campaigns" beyond the immediate geographical boundaries of the conflicts.
Microsoft emphasized the continued targeting of the US and Persian Gulf nations, particularly the UAE and Bahrain due to their normalization of ties with Israel.
Cyber defense chief Gaby Portnoy warned in June that since the outbreak of the Gaza war on October 7, cyberattacks by Iran have become more aggressive, targeting not only Israel but also its allies.
“We have identified that Iran is attacking its allies and other countries for information extortion and damaging digital services,” said Portnoy, head of the Israel National Cyber Directorate (INCD), at the Cyberweek annual conference held at Tel Aviv University.
Portnoy warned that the information stolen from government systems is then used for Iranian cyberterrorism, making Iranian cyber aggression "an international problem, not only an Israeli one, and therefore the solution needs to be international".
Also in August, Microsoft released its Threat Intelligence Report, which provided a comprehensive analysis of how various groups orchestrated influence campaigns aimed at swaying voters, particularly in swing states.
These operations were complemented by intelligence-gathering activities on political campaigns, potentially establishing a foundation for future interference, it said.
Canada designated Samidoun, a pro-Palestinian group responsible for leading "death to Canada" chants and burning the Canadian flag during an anti-Israel protest in Vancouver earlier this month, as a terrorist entity on Tuesday.
Canada's move was made alongside the US Treasury Department's decision to list the group as a specially designated global terrorist entity.
Samidoun, which means "the steadfast ones" in Arabic, had been registered as a non-profit in Canada since March 2021.
"Violent extremism, acts of terrorism or terrorist financing have no place in Canadian society or abroad," Canada's Public Safety Minister Dominic LeBlanc said in a statement.
"The listing of Samidoun as a terrorist entity under the Criminal Code sends a strong message that Canada will not tolerate this type of activity, and will do everything in its power to counter the ongoing threat to Canada’s national security and all people in Canada.”
The US and Canada allege that Samidoun has links with another terrorist-designated group, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP).
Samidoun describe themselves on their official website as being advocates for the release of Palestinian prisoners. The organization did not immediately respond to an Iran International request for comment.
According to Public Safety Canada (PSC) many of those prisoners have ties to assassinations and attacks against Israel.
The PSC says Samidoun has been operating since 2011 and has 20 chapters around the world, including Iran, which Canada designated as a state supporter of terrorism.
Elham Abedini is listed as the coordinator of Samidoun's Iran chapter on Samidoun's official website.
NGO Monitor, a research institute that has been investigating and raising concern over Samidoun to governments around the world since 2018, says the group has an informal connection to the Islamic Republic of Iran through a shared ideology and Iran's pursuit of soft power.
NGO Monitor presents information about Samidoun in the European Union Parliament (March 2023)
The non-profit's communications director Itai Reuveni told Iran International that Iran uses groups like Samidoun to exert its ideology and influence in the West without revealing themselves as the source.
"This fits to the Iranian practice to only use proxies. Samidoun is part of the proxies. Not just Hezbollah and Hamas, but also through soft power proxies " says Reuveni.
The anti-west, anti-Israel and pro-Islamic Republic narrative fits in with Iran's narrative that it wants to export through groups like Samidoun, who have direct access to the West, Reuveni added.
In July, a top US intelligence official revealed that the Iranian government provided financial support for the pro-Palestinian demonstrations rocking US campuses. An Iran International exclusive also found evidence that Iran was behind campus protests rocking McGill university in Canada.
Matthew Levitt, the director of the Reinhard Program on Counterterrorism and Intelligence at The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, said Samidoun was "explicitly active in some of the most vile pro-violence behavior at campus protests. "
Levitt, the author of Hezbollah: The Global Footprint of Lebanon's Party of God, says Iran has definite ties to the PLFP, for which Samidoun was acting as "sham charity" front, according to a US treasury statement on Wednesday.
“Organizations like Samidoun masquerade as charitable actors that claim to provide humanitarian support to those in need, yet in reality divert funds for much-needed assistance to support terrorist groups,” said US treasury official Bradley T. Smith in the statement.
Samidoun and Iran
Samidoun's director, Charlotte Kates, accepted an official "human rights award" in Iran on August 4th, an accolade that was also bestowed on the secretary-general of militant group Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ).
Kates also appeared on Iran State TV, where she praised Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on Israel.
“I spoke about the brave, heroic October 7 operation and the legitimacy of the resistance,” Kates said, dedicating the award to the “martyrs and prisoners of Palestine.”
In a March 2024 Samidoun-hosted webinar, Kates praised Hamas as “the people that are on the frontlines, defending Palestine and fighting for its liberation".
Kates is also under a hate speech investigation in Canada for praising the attack.
Samidoun's website covered Kates's meeting with Kazem Gharibabadi, Iran's Secretary-General of the High Council for Human Rights at the awards ceremony in Tehran. Kates also took part in a joint live interview with Gharibabadi.
Charlotte Kates of Samidoun appearing in Iran.
The existence of Samidoun's Tehran chapter and their participation in Iranian state events could not happen without the Iran government's approval, says NGO Monitor's Reuveni.
Palestinian Islamic Jihad, the PFLP, and the Popular Resistance Committees have themselves cited a relationship with Iran including military support.
Kates's husband, Khaled Barakat, also a director of Samidoun, was identified by the US treasury statement as allegedly backing the fundraising and recruitment efforts to support the PFLP's "terrorist activity against Israel". Israeli security service Shin Bet alleges that Barakat is an active senior member of the PFLP.
The PFLP operates in Gaza and the West Bank and participated in attacking Israeli civilians on Oct. 7, the treasury department added.
Khaled Barakat in a photo that appears on the Samidoun website.
Some Iran watchers like Jason Brodsky say that the PFLP's direct links to Iran are evidence enough linking Samidoun to the Islamic Republic.
Brodsky, policy director of United Against Nuclear Iran (UANI), says Kates' official visits to Iran, appearance on state TV and meeting with high-level officials like Iran's Judiciary Chief Gholamhossein Mohseni Ejei points to an official link with the Islamic Republic.
In 2011 by the United States Department of State and the European Union sanctioned Ejei for his role in suppressing the 2009 Iranian presidential election protests.
"My concern is that the Islamic Republic likes to cultivate these individuals who have access to the West," Brodsky said.
"She is engaged in messaging that is very much in line with the Islamic Republic's ideological outlook," added Brodsky.
According to NGO monitor, Samidoun does not publish financial information, and is only registered in Vancouver, British Columbia.
However, Samidoun is a fiscally sponsored project of the Alliance for Global Justice (AFJG), an Arizona-based organization. The AFJG also is a fiscal sponsor for left-wing initiatives including the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI).
In May 2019, PayPal, DonorBox, and Plaid shut down online donations to Samidoun due to its alleged links to the PFLP.
Samidoun has also been listed as a terrorist entity in Israel and banned in Germany and the Netherlands. The Dutch parliament voted to designate Samidoun a terrorist organization this week.